My wife and I were planning to go camping in the Adirondack High Peaks region. I looked for campgrounds near Lake Placid and Saranac Lake. I found a KOA but it was up around Wilmington, and I wanted to find something with a shorter drive from Rochester, NY. I found another campground with all kinds of amenities, but as I tried to book, I found it required a 3 day minimum stay. Darn it. I found another campground, but found that the tent sites were located on islands and you needed a boat to reach them (good thing I read more before booking one). Then I tried Rollins Pond Campground. It is a state campground. I went ahead a booked a site.
There are two campgrounds here: Fish Creek Pond Campground & Rollins Pond Campground. Fish Creek Pond Campground is more family oriented, and has it’s site located directly on the pond, and are all squished close together. Rollins Pond Campground offers more quiet, and has buffers between the sites.
As we arrived in the area, we found that we had to drive through Fish Creek Pond Campground, to reach the entrance of Rollins Pond Campground. There were about half a dozen cars in front of us at the check in. The check in process was agonizingly slow, and took us about us between 20 minutes and half an hour to get in.
We drove to our camp site. 80% of the campsites are located on the water, and the rest are across the road. Our site was not one of the 80% on the water. Reserve America listed our site as Drive Tent Prime. I am still trying to figure out what “Prime” is. The best thing about our site is it was near the bathrooms. The only things found on our site were a picnic table and a cement block firepit that looked kind of busted up.
The bathrooms were dimly lit, and not very clean. Often we found the toilets clogged up. And most of the bathrooms had only toilets and a couple sinks with cold running water. There were also mirrors, but because of the dim lighting, they weren’t extremely helpful.
There were a couple shower buildings at the campground, but we would have had to get into the can, drive to them as they were quite a ways away from our campsite. We never did.
There were water faucets located along the road for campers to use, but these were located a distance apart, and required a short walk to get water.
I looked at fishing in the pond (from a camp site on the water), but the water near shore was too shallow to try fishing from shore, and I didn’t have a boat. There was a place near the entrance where I saw people fishing on a small dock. But I would have had to drive to it, and just never got around to it.
There were a handfull of activities scheduled each day. We checked out one listed as Mountain Pies. We weren’t sure what mountain pies were. So we got in the car, and drove to it as it was a long ways away from our site. Mountain pies seem to be pie filling spread on white bread, and toasted over a fire. We didn’t bother with them, and headed back to our campsite.
Overall, I just wasn’t impressed. I will not likely stay at this campground next time. Maybe I was spoiled by our last trip to Old Forge where we stayed at a private owned campground.

Wow! My experience at Rollins Pond has been much better. I have been camping there nearly every summer since I was a kid. We were there this summer as well…no clogged toilets, the bathrooms were decently lit, FREE showers at the shower building and our sites were all on the water (we’ve walked the entire campground to find the ones that meet our criteria). I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy your stay but maybe you’ll give it another try. We LOVE it!
Comment by Pam — October 22, 2006 @ 9:12 am
Would you be able to tell me where there are 4 good sites that would be good for little kids (no cliffs) and have beachy areas near the water? It seems that the sites we know of are all taken already. (at Rollins Pond)
Comment by Melissa — October 29, 2006 @ 3:09 pm
I am looking for a canoe rental company that will drop me at Rollins pond and pick up the canoe on Lake Flower in Saranac Lake
Comment by Bobby — December 1, 2006 @ 10:46 pm
Sorry you had such a bad experience at Rollins! Have been every year (except 4 during college) since birth. My family and I are in love with this park and the Adirondack Mountains. You can canoe right into the Saranac Lake Chain from the pond. And to answer the last comment/question there is a boat livery on the pond where you can rent canoes for a few hours or days! Leaving for the park in 6 more days to embark on a canoe adventure. Highly recommend giving the park a try and enjoying the lakes starting at this park.
Comment by Paul — July 14, 2007 @ 6:10 pm
It sounds to me like you don’t actually know what camping is. Rollins has great facilities and is absolutely amazing. I have never heard complaints about the campground and I have gone there many times with many different people. Everybody always loves it. I’ve been to many campgrounds and Rollins’ facilities nothing to complain about. Perhaps next time you should forgo the camping all together because it sounds to me that you aren’t cut out for it.
Comment by A Happy Camper — July 24, 2007 @ 8:17 am
We just camped for 4 days at the Fish Creek Pond Campsite (July 2007) but wish we had stayed at Rollins Pond instead (the two campsites are adjacent). Fish Creek Pond has many lakeside campsites that are packed tightly together….there isn’t any buffer between sites so no privacy. The campsites have a nice lake on one side (you can tie up your boat at the site) and a road on the other so while there is a nice lake view there is also a steady stream of cars, bikes and people (15 mph speed limit). Fish Creek Pond campsite attracts LOTS of RVs including HUGE land yachts. Since we are tent campers we felt somewhat overwhelmed and the motor-boat and Ski-doo traffic on the lake was often quite noisy. Toilet facilities are adequate but no hot water. Coin-operated showers are in a separate building far removed from many sites (over 1.5 miles from some sites).
Rollins Pond Campground is much more secluded than Fish Creek. The sites we saw were lakeside sites more widely spaced than Fish Creek with privacy from trees and plants. Rollins Pond is a better choice for tent campers who value privacy and quiet and natural surroundings and that’s where we will head next summer! Let the RV crowd stay at Fish Creek Pond!
David
Comment by David — July 30, 2007 @ 1:17 pm
I have to agree with RJ. When I was younger these campgrounds were clean, quiet and one of the best around but as the years have gone by the campgrounds - both Fish Creek and Rolands have gotten way too busy, noisy and dirty for my taste. I now frequent Lewey Lake, I find it more to my liking.
Comment by SB — August 15, 2007 @ 11:00 am
We have camped extensively in the east and we find that by far the Fish Creek / Rollins combo out shines anything else out there. Yes maybe if your a more suburban type camper, then a KOA is more you’re style, with pools, cabin and cable tv, but if you like to be close to nature and endless options to enjoy the outdoors, Fish Creek / Rollins is hard to beat.
We find it always clean, lots of water taps, abundant showers facilities (have never had to line up) and has an amazing ambience. For more social camping and boating, Fish Creek is your choice, Rollins if you like quiet and more privacy… best of both worlds in one place.
Best part is the easy access to some of the best canoeing/kayak around, as well as access to Upper Saranac, one of our favorite lakes in upstate NY.
Comment by Dave — February 19, 2008 @ 1:35 pm